The True Post (Web News)Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney delivered a speech on Thursday in Quebec City that has sparked significant political controversy across the country, particularly in Quebec
. In his address, Carney referenced the historic Plains of Abraham and described the battle as the beginning of a “partnership” between French and English populations. This interpretation has been criticized by several Quebec leaders as a misrepresentation of history.
During his visit to Quebec City, Carney said that while the Plains of Abraham was a battlefield, it was also the place where Canada chose a path of unity over conquest, collaboration over division, and harmony over forced assimilation. He emphasized the importance of Canadian unity in the face of external threats, stating, “Canada is at its strongest when we stand together.”
The speech came shortly after Carney’s return from the World Economic Forum in Davos, where he spoke about defending Canadian values, addressing the risks of artificial intelligence, and demonstrating how Canada can remain open and secure at the same time.
However, Quebec’s Minister of the French Language, Jean‑François Roberge, reacted strongly on Friday, claiming that Carney attempted to rewrite history. He argued that labeling the British conquest as a “partnership” and “harmony” overlooks the reality of forced assimilation. Roberge suggested that Carney reconsider his speech, pointing out that truth and honesty should guide historical interpretation.
Parti Québécois leader Paul St‑Pierre Plamondon also criticized Carney, accusing him of distorting history. He warned that the federal government continues to make promises to counter rising separatist sentiments that may never be fulfilled. Plamondon cited former Prime Minister Jean Chrétien, asserting that Canada’s foundation has long been built on misrepresentations which federal institutions have repeatedly perpetuated.
Bloc Québécois leader Yves‑François Blanchet also rejected Carney’s perspective, calling the celebration of the Plains of Abraham battle and the end of New France an “insultingly inaccurate” portrayal of Quebec history. According to Blanchet, the defeat led to deprivation of rights for French Canadians, life under English rule, and ongoing attempts at assimilation.
On the other hand, Federal Finance Minister François‑Philippe Champagne defended Carney, stating that amid global uncertainty, it was important for the Prime Minister to clearly articulate his vision for Canada. Champagne emphasized that national unity is essential for the country’s future and stability.
