
The House of Commons has passed second reading of Bill C-41, the Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act, by a vote of 225 to 89. The vote took place on Tuesday, November 17, and the bill now moves to the justice committee for detailed study.
What the bill would change
Bill C-41 would make two major changes to Canada’s assisted dying law. First, it would allow advance requests for medical assistance in dying. A person living with a degenerative condition such as dementia or ALS could ask in advance for an assisted death to be carried out after they lose the capacity to consent.
Second, the bill would permanently exclude mental illness as the sole underlying condition for medical assistance in dying. That would cancel a planned expansion of eligibility that is currently set to take effect on March 17, 2027. The government introduced the bill on October 27.
A debate cut short
The vote came after the Liberal government moved to limit debate on the bill. Justice Minister Sean Fraser’s time allocation motion passed on Monday by 163 votes to 149, leaving one further day for second reading debate.
Conservative MP Tamara Jansen called the move absolutely shameful, saying MPs had not yet seen the government’s own analysis of how the bill could affect Canadians’ Charter rights. Bloc Quebecois MP Martin Champoux accused the government of muzzling debate on a measure that deals with life and death.
What happens next
The bill will now be studied clause by clause by the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights, which can propose amendments before it returns to the Commons for third reading.
Time is short. The bill must clear both the Commons and the Senate before March 17, 2027. If it does not, the temporary exclusion expires and medical assistance in dying would become available to people whose only underlying condition is a mental illness.
